data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6d82e/6d82e238bdf8670ac5f0bd0f0ce8b01272668640" alt=""
I was listening to “A Dime a Dozen,” by Carla Thomas, the other day.
I love almost everything about this song. It’s pretty perfect, except for those lyrics, which are, as near as I can tell: “You’re so sweet, sweeter than apples, and just like an apple, nobody can sample.” There’s some other stuff in there that I can’t quite make out but it doesn’t sound promising.
I don’t need brilliant lyrics with every song. I’m fine with words that merely sound cool even if they don’t make much sense to me. I also don’t mind if they are just the simple lyrics of a more innocent era. My favorite song of all time is “Good Lovin’,” by The Rascals, so I am by no means a lyrics snob. But “A Dime a Dozen” did make me start to wonder how bad the lyrics would have to be to make an otherwise cool song unlistenable.
So, what song do you think has the biggest gap between cool music and crappy lyrics?
Conversely, what song do you think has the biggest gap between crappy music and cool lyrics? (I’m guessing there has to be a Dylan song to fit this bill.)