In our Friday Flashack discussion of Roomie’s Record Collection, Townsman k. made mention of a related phenomenon: record collection shack-up overlap that you first address when you and the love of your life decide to cohabitate. In his case, he and his wife’s pre-shacking up record collection only included one overlapping album. I’m curious to know what you and your live-in loves have found overlapping in your single-guy/gal collections—and what, if anything, you consciously did with the overlapping albums (ie, keep or sell, how they would be filed, which one would be selected for play, etc).
I remember my wife and I overlapping most on our Elvis Costello collections. We did not get rid of the redundant albums, but for some reason (“Because you’re so controlling!” my wife might say) her Costello albums got shoved to a “reserve” bin while mine kept in rotation. I also remember one time taping over an old cassette in her collection of an album that I owned on vinyl. She got mad at me because the cassette case of her Van Morrison album was hand decorated by whichever old college friend taped the album for her. Sorry.